Newsletter #122

How to Write a B2B Newsletter People Actually Read

October 29, 2024 · 6 min read

To write a B2B newsletter people actually read, treat it as a relationship, not a distribution channel. Lead with value instead of product pitches, use the same sections every issue, write like a person talks, send on a fixed day and judge it by opens, reopens and replies. Here’s how monday.com and Exit Five do it.

A favorite quote about newsletters comes from Ann Handley:

An email newsletter is not a distribution strategy, it’s a relationship-builder.

Ann Handley

If your B2B newsletter isn’t getting traction, the tough truth is that you’re probably treating it like a distribution strategy. The best example of the relationship approach is monday insights, the thought leadership newsletter from monday.com. It grew to 3.7 million subscribers with a unique open rate around 55%, compared with a 30% benchmark for monday.com’s other marketing emails. Its lead writer, Arielle Gordis, shared the exact strategy behind it. Here are the rules that make it work, plus the ones we use on the Exit Five Newsletter.

B2B newsletter structure: a template you can copy

Readers should know what they’re getting every week. monday insights uses the same sections in every issue. Use it as a starting template and swap in what your readers care about.

SectionWhat goes in itmonday insights example
TrendsWhat’s changing in your reader’s world this weekWorkplace trends, from new research to headline-worthy news about work
Big shiftOne topic that’s reshaping your reader’s jobAI updates and the future of work
Practical adviceSomething the reader can use at work right awayManager’s Corner: team motivation, conflict, giving feedback, communication
Something lightA conversation starter or surprise“Water cooler chatter” to bring up with coworkers
Reason to come backA hook that sends readers to past issuesA fun fact that encourages people to go back to the previous newsletter
Signature elementThe thing nobody else doesA cartoon from a New Yorker cartoonist
Sign-off and P.S.A personal close and one clear askNot a monday insights section. Dave Gerhardt’s rule: the P.S. reinforces the call to action

Rule 1: Lead with value, not your product

The vision behind monday insights was simple: no sales pitch, no product plugs, just relevant insights that make readers better at their jobs. The CEO wanted something professionals could depend on every week, so good that readers wouldn’t want to unsubscribe.

If you’re going to do thought leadership, go all in on value. Show up in your readers’ inboxes with something they need to know. That’s how you build loyalty, and it’s what earns you the occasional ask.

Rule 2: Use the same structure every issue

A consistent structure creates a consistent reading experience. Readers find their go-to sections and look forward to them, which matters most for busy leaders scanning for something they can use right away. Keep the sections fixed and the content inside them fresh.

Rule 3: Write like you talk (newsletter writing tips)

Dave Gerhardt calls copywriting selling at scale. His 5 non-negotiable rules for copywriting apply to every newsletter:

  • Write like you talk. Not like a marketer. Like a real person writing an email to a friend.
  • Write choppy copy. Short sentences. Each line plays off the next. Don’t write an essay.
  • First line, second line. The subject line gets the open, the first line gets people to the second, and so on all the way to the CTA. The P.S. reinforces the CTA.
  • Load up on pronouns. You, me, we, I. It’s how people talk, and in B2B you’re still writing to people.
  • Fill it with real examples. Real screenshots and photos, not stock images, so readers know you’re real.

Rule 4: Make the from name and subject line earn the open

The from name matters almost as much as the subject line. Jay Schwedelson of subjectline.com shared data showing it can affect open rates by as much as 31%. That’s why the Exit Five Newsletter switched from a person’s name alone to “[Name] from Exit Five,” so readers know who sent it.

Personalization still drives opens, but first names in subject lines are overused. Tell people who they are instead, so they think “wait, that’s me”:

  • By industry: “Just for retail professionals”
  • By company: “Litmus needs to know this”
  • By job title: “The best CIOs are doing this 1 thing”

Rule 5: Pull topics from real conversations

Arielle didn’t guess at topics. Ideas came from research, conversations inside the company and conversations with friends, so she knew a topic would resonate before she wrote it. For a Mother’s Day issue on supporting parents on your team, she talked to parents at monday.com about what their managers do that really helps, and what they wish their managers did more of.

When a topic lands, reuse it. The monday.com team turns topics that resonate into video for LinkedIn or blog posts to extend their reach.

Rule 6: Build a weekly writing rhythm

Consistency comes from a process, not inspiration. Arielle’s week looked like this:

  1. Research current workplace trends early in the week
  2. Draft the newsletter mid-week
  3. Review it (“probably seven times”)
  4. Send it every Tuesday

Rule 7: Measure engagement, and don’t trust every click

monday insights barely links out, so the team measures success with opens. Its total open rate, which counts people reopening issues, can reach up to 95%, a sign readers come back to the same issue more than once. If your opens, shares and reopens are strong, you’re doing something right.

Be careful with click data, though. Bots and security software often click every link in an email before it’s delivered. One test from email experts Jay Schwedelson, Beth O’Malley and Jaina Mistry: send an email at 2 AM and check clicks in the first 30 minutes. You’re not that popular at 2 AM, so those clicks are almost all bots. Use that baseline to discount your normal click rates.

Two more habits from the same experts: reply to every reply, because most brands don’t respond at all, and don’t send all-image emails, because AI inbox summaries need text to work with.

Rule 8: Just start

When Arielle started, she was overwhelmed. As a perfectionist, nothing felt good enough, until her manager encouraged her to just start. It became the best part of her job. Your first issue won’t be perfect, and nobody expects it to be. The sooner you start, the faster you learn what works. You don’t need millions of subscribers to give your audience value.

B2B newsletter examples: monday insights and the Exit Five Newsletter

  • monday insights (monday.com): a no-pitch thought leadership newsletter with a fixed structure, 3.7 million subscribers and a unique open rate around 55%.
  • The Exit Five Newsletter: what’s working in B2B marketing right now, in about five minutes, with lessons from 15+ years in B2B marketing, strategies from top practitioners, and real stats, examples and tools you can take back to your team.

See what’s really working in B2B marketing

Join 40,000+ marketers getting real campaign examples, practical strategy ideas, and lessons from B2B teams growing from $1M to $1B.

Frequently asked questions

How do you write a B2B newsletter?

Treat it as a relationship, not a distribution channel. Lead with value instead of product pitches, use the same sections every issue, write like you talk with short sentences and real examples, and send on a fixed day. Then measure opens, reopens and replies, and keep improving the sections readers come back for.

What content should go in a B2B thought leadership newsletter?

Use a fixed set of sections. monday.com’s monday insights newsletter runs workplace trends, AI and the future of work, practical advice for managers, water cooler chatter, a fun fact that points to the last issue and a cartoon. Swap in what your readers care about, but keep it useful and free of product pitches.

How often should you send a B2B newsletter?

Pick a cadence you can keep and stick to it. monday.com’s monday insights newsletter goes out every Tuesday, with research early in the week, a draft mid-week and several reviews before sending. Consistency matters more than frequency, because readers learn when to expect you and which sections to look for.

How do you measure a B2B newsletter’s success?

Look at engagement, not just clicks. monday.com’s monday insights newsletter measures unique opens (around 55%) and total opens including reopens (up to 95%). Discount click rates for bots by checking clicks on an email sent at 2 AM, and treat replies as a signal readers see a real person behind the email.

How do you get more people to open a B2B newsletter?

Fix the from name and the subject line first. A clear from name like “[Name] from Exit Five” tells readers who it’s from, and from-name changes can move open rates by as much as 31%. In subject lines, tell people who they are by industry, company or job title instead of using their first name.

Leading marketing at a B2B company?

CMO Council is Exit Five’s private CMO community — a vetted, NDA-protected peer network for VPs of Marketing and CMOs to share real budget numbers, strategy, and support.

Join the CMO Council